
Carl Nettles Reynolds, Major League Baseball player, was born to a farming family in LaRue, Henderson County, Texas, on February 1, 1903. He was the fourth child of Robert Peel Reynolds and Ann Elizabeth (Nettles) Reynolds. Reynolds attended the Alexander Institute (later Lon Morris College, closed in 2012) in Jacksonville, Texas. Moving on to Southwestern University in Georgetown, he was a multi-sports star and earned letters in baseball, football, basketball, and track. Primarily a shortstop on the baseball team, Reynolds was discovered during a game between Southwestern and Trinity College in Waxahachie in 1926 by Roy and Bessie Largent, a husband-and-wife scouting team employed by the Chicago White Sox. Roy Largent had come to the game to scout a Trinity pitcher but was impressed by Reynolds, who was subsequently signed by the duo. In early 1927 Reynolds, who had become a football and basketball coach at Lon Morris College, resigned to join the White Sox spring training camp in Shreveport.
Reynolds’s first stop as a professional was close to home, as the White Sox assigned him to the Palestine Pals of the Class D Lone Star League. Converted to an outfielder, he led the team in hits (180) and batting average (.372). Intrigued, the White Sox called Reynolds up for the final month of the season. He made his big-league debut on September 1, 1927, against the Cleveland Indians and got his first big league hit the next day. In 1928 Reynolds had his first full season with the White Sox, for whom he hit .323 in part-time duty. Promoted to full-time starter (primarily in right field) in 1929, he hit .317 and led the team in runs batted in (RBIs), albeit with a mere sixty-seven (the lack of offensive power was a major reason for the team’s 59–93 record). After the season, on November 9, 1929, Reynolds married eighteen-year-old Ruth Matilda Dayvault, who later became a nurse. They had two sons, Carl Jr. (born 1934) and Robert (born 1942).
In 1930 Reynolds had his best season. He drove home 104 runs while batting .359 with 202 hits, including eighteen triples and twenty-two home runs. Three of those home runs were consecutive - including two against future Hall-of-Famer Red Ruffing - and took place on July 2 in the second game of a doubleheader against the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium. After Reynolds slipped to .290 due to injuries in 1931, the White Sox traded him to the Washington Senators.
While with the Senators in 1932, Reynolds was involved in an incident that made headlines nationwide. During the first game of a July 4 doubleheader against the Yankees in Washington, Reynolds crashed into Yankee catcher Bill Dickey while scoring. It wasn’t clear that Reynolds had touched the plate, however, so his teammates in the Senators’ dugout yelled at him to go back and do so. Dickey, who had been knocked out in a play at the plate during a recent game, thought Reynolds was returning to take another shot at him, so he punched him. This was the only blow struck, but it broke Reynolds’s jaw. American League President Will Harridge fined Dickey $1,000 and suspended him for thirty days. With his jaws wired shut, Reynolds was out for almost six weeks. The injury led to a life-threatening incident. On July 19 Reynolds was in a taxicab when he became ill and started to vomit. Thinking quickly, his wife snipped the wires with a pair of manicure scissors so Reynolds could open his mouth, thus averting death by aspiration. When the Yankees returned to Washington in August, Reynolds and Dickey were both back in action, and police officers were stationed on the field to deter any misconduct. The players remained docile.
Reynolds finished the 1932 season with a creditable offensive year (a .305 batting average in 406 at bats). Nevertheless, the Senators traded him to the St. Louis Browns before the 1933 season. Reynolds responded with a decent season (a .286 batting average in 475 at bats), but there were few witnesses. The combination of the Great Depression, the team’s poor record (55-96), and competition from the St. Louis Cardinals’ colorful Gashouse Gang assured the Browns a dismal year at the box office at Sportsman’s Park (ironically, the Browns owned the ballpark and leased it out to the Cardinals). The Browns attracted just 88,113 fans for the entire season. It was not their worst showing, as they drew just 80,922 in 1935 - the all-time major league low.
At season’s end Reynolds was dealt to the Boston Red Sox. In the 1934 season he batted .303 and drove home eighty-six runs in 113 games. After he hit .270 in part-time duty in Boston the following season, Reynolds was traded back to the Senators, where he had a similar season (.276). Though he had a .306 lifetime batting average with 1,135 hits, the Senators traded him to a minor league club, the Minneapolis Millers of the American Association, before the 1937 season. Reynolds batted .355 with 218 hits, 17 home runs, and 110 runs batted in. At the conclusion of the minor league season, his contract was purchased by the Chicago Cubs, and he spent the remainder of the 1937 season with them. In 1938 the Cubs won the National League pennant. In the ensuing World Series, however, the Cubs were swept by the Yankees in four games, and Reynolds was hitless in thirteen plate appearances with just one base on balls. Nevertheless, the losing team received a paycheck of $4,675 per player.
Reynolds returned to the Cubs in 1939, but it was the worst year of his career, as he hit just .246 in part-time duty. At the age of thirty-six his major league career was over. He had a lifetime batting average of .302 and 1,357 hits. Reynolds had been an asset in the outfield, as he had a strong arm (he threw and batted right-handed), particularly important in center and right field, where he played most of his games. He was also fleet of foot for a heavy-set player (6 feet, 194 pounds).
In 1940 Reynolds accepted a position as player–manager with the Los Angeles Angels of the Pacific Coast League. This was his final year as a player. In 1941 he worked for the Angels as a coach and scout but did not play. After the season Reynolds returned to his farm in Wharton, Texas. He had purchased the farm in 1934 and spent the rest of his life there. As a prominent citizen in Wharton, he served on the boards of a local bank, a hospital, and Wharton County Junior College. Reynolds’s eldest son, Carl Jr., a first baseman, played baseball at Rice University. After graduating in 1956, he played two seasons of minor league ball in the Chicago Cubs system. He also carried on the family tradition of farming.
During the last years of his life, Reynolds suffered from myelofibrosis and myeloid metaplasia. He died on May 29, 1978, at Methodist Hospital of Houston. He was buried at Wharton City Cemetery next to his wife Ruth, who had died in 1974. His son Robert died in 2005, while Carl Jr. died in 2019. Both are also interred in the family plot. In 1971 Reynolds was inducted into the Texas Sports Hall of Fame. In 1990 he was posthumously enshrined in the Southwestern University Hall of Honor.
Source
Wharton City Cemetery
Wharton
29° 18.601, -096° 05.490